In this article, the reader will find a comprehensive comparison of various brands of locking pliers, also known as Vise Grips. The video that is being discussed in this article showcases the testing of locking pliers from brands such as Knipex, Irwin, Milwaukee, Craftsman, and many others. The testing focuses on the strength, grip, and durability of these pliers on mild steel and high carbon steel, with each brand pushed to the point of failure. The article emphasizes the unbiased testing process and mentions the prices and origins of each brand. It also provides performance results for each brand, highlighting the best performing brand in terms of gripping strength and discussing the condition of the pliers and any damage experienced during testing. The article aims to offer valuable information to individuals who are looking to purchase locking pliers from various brands.
Comparison of Locking Pliers (VISE GRIPS) from Various Brands
Introduction
Locking pliers, also known as VISE GRIPS, are invaluable tools that provide a secure grip on different objects. However, not all locking pliers are created equal. In this comprehensive article, we will compare locking pliers from various brands to determine which ones offer the best performance, durability, and value for money. We will assess their gripping strength, cutting performance, ease of use, and more. Whether you’re a professional tradesperson or a DIY enthusiast, this comparison will help you make an informed decision when choosing the right locking pliers for your needs.
Brands Tested
We have tested locking pliers from a wide range of brands, including:
- Knipex
- Irwin
- Milwaukee
- Craftsman
- Tekton
- Harden
- Pittsburgh
- Williams
- Crescent
- Grip On
- Stanley Fatmax
- Malco Eagle Grip
By testing products from these popular brands, we aim to provide a comprehensive overview of the quality and performance offered in the locking pliers market.
This image is property of i.ytimg.com.
Testing Process
To ensure unbiased testing and accurate results, we follow a rigorous and standardized testing process. The pliers were tested on various materials, including mild steel and high carbon steel. We evaluated their strength, grip, and durability by subjecting them to different tests, pushing them to their limits.
Performance Results
Best Performing Brand in Grip Strength (Grade 5 Bolt)
In terms of gripping strength, one brand stood out from the rest. Malco Eagle Grip locking pliers performed exceptionally well, providing a squeezing force of 1053 inch pounds, making it the best performing brand in this category. The aggressive grip of Malco pliers allowed them to dig into the bolt securely, ensuring maximum grip.
Comparison of Gripping Strength
Craftsman and Irwin locking pliers also performed impressively, providing a gripping strength of 543 inch pounds. These brands offer a reliable and secure grip, making them ideal choices for various tasks.
Cutting Performance
When it comes to cutting performance, different brands showcased varying results. Irwin Vice Grips performed the best when cutting through a 16 penny nail, requiring a force of 140 pounds. Williams locking pliers performed even better, cutting through the nail at 120 pounds. Other brands such as Crescent and Milwaukee also performed well in this test.
Half-Inch Socket Extension Grip
Malco locking pliers proved to be the top performer in gripping a half-inch socket extension made of high carbon steel. They held up the best, ensuring a secure grip. Other brands such as Irwin, Stanley Fat Max, and Milwaukee also demonstrated excellent gripping strength in this test.
Unlocking Ease
Different brands showed varying levels of ease when it came to unlocking the pliers. Malco locking pliers required the most force to unlock, followed by Grip-On pliers. On the other hand, Milwaukee pliers were the easiest to unlock, providing a smooth and effortless unlocking experience.
Durability and Failure Load
In terms of durability, Malco pliers proved to be the most durable, withstanding significant pressure before failure. Milwaukee pliers also showcased excellent durability. These brands offer locking pliers that can handle tough tasks and withstand heavy loads.
This image is property of images.unsplash.com.
Condition of Pliers
During the testing process, we evaluated the condition of the pliers, paying close attention to the teeth. The teeth of the Malco Eagle Grip locking pliers experienced only a small amount of damage, highlighting their durability and longevity. On the other hand, Pittsburgh and Tekton pliers had some issues with the 16 penny nail test, causing more damage to their teeth. It is important to consider the condition of the pliers, especially the teeth, as it directly impacts their gripping performance.
Price and Origin
When considering locking pliers, the price and origin can play a significant role in decision-making. Our tests included brands with varying price ranges to provide options for different budgets. It is worth noting that the most expensive brand we tested was Malco. Despite its higher price, Malco locking pliers offer exceptional performance and durability. Additionally, Malco pliers have a smooth adjustment screw and are made in the USA, ensuring quality craftsmanship. Other brands also offer more affordable options while still delivering reliable performance. Craftsman and Irwin Vice Grips, in particular, are recommended brands for those looking for affordable options without compromising on quality.
This image is property of images.unsplash.com.
Conclusion
Locking pliers are essential tools for any professional or DIY enthusiast, providing a secure grip and versatility in various applications. After thorough testing, we can confidently recommend certain brands based on their performance and durability. Malco Eagle Grips emerged as the top performer, offering impressive gripping strength, durability, and excellent teeth condition. Craftsman and Irwin Vice Grips also showcased reliable performance in gripping strength and cutting performance. We hope that this comprehensive comparison has provided valuable insights and assisted you in making an informed decision when selecting locking pliers to suit your needs. Remember, when working on projects, the quality of your tools is crucial for achieving outstanding results.
