Project Farm LLC, in their latest video, tests the durability and performance of a wide variety of screwdriver brands. The video aims to evaluate the wear resistance and grip of these screwdrivers by installing and removing 50 screws into a pressure-treated 4×4 board. Slotted screwdrivers are specifically tested for cam out, durability, and impact resistance, while handles are subjected to solvent resistance tests. The video emphasizes fair and unbiased testing, as all screwdrivers are purchased and no sponsorships are accepted. However, it is important to note that the video is intended for entertainment purposes only, and viewers must assume responsibility for their own results if they choose to rely on the information provided.
Project Farm LLC’s extensive testing covers several brands, including Pittsburgh, Craftsman, Tecton, Channel Lock, Fila, Milwaukee, Wearer, Vessel, Klein Tools, PB Swiss, and Wiha. Among the brands, the Pittsburgh screwdrivers, priced at only $7 for 12 pieces, performed unsatisfactorily due to their thin and soft blade. In contrast, the Craftsman brand, costing $17 for 8 screwdrivers, showcased thicker flutes and excelled in driving in and removing screws. The Wearer brand, priced at $57 for 6 screwdrivers, performed the best overall, requiring less downward force and experiencing minimal wear. For those on a budget, the Craftsman brand is recommended, while Milwaukee and WIA are suggested for their good performance.
Testing Durability and Performance of Various Screwdriver Brands
Overview
This article provides a comprehensive analysis of the durability and performance of various screwdriver brands. The testing was conducted by Project Farm LLC, an independent testing agency known for delivering fair and unbiased results. The aim of the testing was to evaluate the wear resistance, grip resistance (cam out), durability, impact resistance, and solvent resistance of the different screwdriver brands.
Introduction to Project Farm LLC
Project Farm LLC is a reputable testing agency known for conducting rigorous and unbiased tests on a wide range of products. They aim to provide consumers with honest and accurate information to help them make informed purchasing decisions. The agency does not accept sponsorships, ensuring that the testing remains objective and unbiased.
Methodology of Testing
The testing of screwdriver brands involved installing and removing 50 screws into a pressure-treated 4×4 board. The slotted screwdrivers were tested for cam out, durability, and impact resistance. The handles of the screwdrivers were tested for solvent resistance. Each brand was independently purchased by Project Farm LLC to maintain an unbiased testing process.
Objective and Purpose of the Test
The objective of the test was to evaluate the durability and performance of various screwdriver brands in different scenarios. The purpose was to provide viewers with valuable information that could help them make informed decisions when purchasing screwdrivers. It is important to note that the video is for entertainment purposes, and viewers assume responsibility for the results if they rely on the information portrayed.
Screwdriver Brands Tested
Craftsman
Milwaukee
Wera
Wiha
Klein Tools
Felo
PB Swiss
Tekton
Pittsburgh
Channel Lock
Vessel
WIA
Detecting Klein
The following screwdriver brands were tested: Craftsman, Milwaukee, Wera, Wiha, Klein Tools, Felo, PB Swiss, Tekton, Pittsburgh, Channel Lock, Vessel, WIA, and Detecting Klein. These brands were chosen to represent a diverse range of options available on the market.
This image is property of i.ytimg.com.
Evaluation Criteria
Wear Resistance
The wear resistance of the screwdrivers was evaluated by installing and removing 50 screws into a pressure-treated 4×4 board. The extent of wear and tear on the screwdriver blades was assessed to determine the longevity of each brand.
Grip Resistance (Cam Out)
The grip resistance, or cam out, refers to the ability of the screwdriver to maintain a firm grip on the screw head without slipping. This criterion was tested by installing and removing screws, evaluating the ease of use and the need for exerting downward force to prevent cam out.
Durability
Durability was assessed by testing the screwdrivers’ ability to withstand repeated impact and use without bending, twisting, or breaking. The materials used for the handles and shafts were evaluated to determine their robustness.
Impact Resistance
The screwdrivers were tested for their ability to handle stress from hammer blows. The performance of each brand was assessed based on whether the screwdriver maintained its structural integrity and functionality after being subjected to impact.
Solvent Resistance
The handles of the screwdrivers were tested for their resistance to solvents. Brake parts cleaner was used to evaluate the effect on handle quality and durability.
Test Results and Analysis
Overview of Findings
The overall findings of the test indicated that there were significant differences in the durability and performance of the various screwdriver brands. Some brands performed exceptionally well, while others showed signs of wear and required more downward force to prevent cam out.
Pittsburgh
The Pittsburgh brand, which is a budget option costing $7 for 12 screwdrivers, performed poorly in the testing. The thin and soft blade of the Pittsburgh screwdriver resulted in early wear and limited durability.
Craftsman
The Craftsman brand, priced at $17 for 8 screwdrivers, proved to be a reliable option. The thicker flutes of the Craftsman screwdrivers provided better strength and resistance. They performed well in driving in and removing screws, and the screwdrivers experienced minimal wear after the test.
Tekton
The Tekton brand, priced at $24 for 8 screwdrivers, featured thick flutes but required a significant amount of downward force during installation. Despite experiencing wear, the Tekton screwdrivers demonstrated durability.
Channel Lock
The Channel Lock brand, priced at $33 for 6 screwdrivers, performed better than the Tekton but still required a considerable amount of downward force. The flutes of the Channel Lock screwdrivers did not bend or twist, indicating good strength.
Felo
The Felo brand, priced at $40 for 6 screwdrivers, had thin flutes but performed well in the testing. However, they experienced wear after the test, suggesting limited durability.
Milwaukee
The Milwaukee brand, priced at $42 for 6 screwdrivers, performed well with less downward force required during installation. The wear on the Milwaukee screwdrivers was similar to that of the Craftsman, indicating good durability.
Wera
The Wera brand, priced at $57 for 6 screwdrivers, performed the best in the testing. The Wera screwdrivers required less downward force during installation and showed significantly less wear than other brands.
Vessel
The Vessel brand performed well in the testing, with varying levels of downward force required to prevent cam out. The Vessel screwdrivers demonstrated good durability and wear resistance.
Klein Tools
Klein Tools, PB Swiss, Wiha, and WIA brands were also tested and performed well with varying levels of downward force and wear. These brands offer reliable options for consumers seeking high-quality screwdrivers.
Detecting Klein
Detecting Klein and Milwaukee brands were praised as top-performing American brands in the testing.
This image is property of images.unsplash.com.
Results: Wear Resistance and Driving Force
Key Findings
The testing revealed significant differences in wear resistance and the driving force required for the various screwdriver brands. German brands, such as Wera and Wiha, dominated in wear resistance and had the advantage of requiring less downward force during use.
Comparison of Driving Force Required
The driving force required to prevent cam out varied among the tested brands. Brands like Craftsman, Milwaukee, and WIA performed well with minimal downward force, while others required more pressure during installation.
Comparison of Wear Resistance
The wear resistance of the screwdrivers was assessed based on the condition of the flutes after installing and removing 50 screws. German brands, such as Wera and Wiha, demonstrated superior wear resistance compared to other brands.
Impact of Blade Thickness
The blade thickness of the screwdrivers played a role in their performance and durability. Thicker blades, as seen in brands like Wera and WIA, resulted in better performance under high force situations.
German Brands Dominating
It was evident from the testing that German brands, including Wera, Wiha, and WIA, performed exceptionally well in terms of wear resistance, driving force required, and overall durability.
Variation in Performance
While German brands dominated in wear resistance and driving force, other brands such as Craftsman, Milwaukee, and Vessel also performed well, albeit with some variations in wear and grip resistance.
Results: Cam Out Load Test
Key Findings
The cam out load test assessed the ability of the screwdrivers to maintain a firm grip on the screw head without slipping. Milwaukee, Wera, and PB Swiss brands demonstrated the best resistance to cam out, indicating their superior grip performance.
Comparison of Brands’ Cam Out Performance
The cam out performance of the various screwdriver brands was compared, with Milwaukee, Wera, and PB Swiss brands showing the highest resistance to camming out.
Strength and Resistance to Cam Out
The strength and resistance to cam out were evaluated based on the ability of the screwdrivers to maintain a secure grip on the screw head. Milwaukee, Wera, and PB Swiss brands excelled in this aspect.
This image is property of images.unsplash.com.
Results: Blade Thickness Test
Key Findings
The blade thickness test analyzed the thickness of the screwdriver blades and their ability to handle high force situations. Wera and WIA brands had the thickest blades and performed the best, breaking the bolts at high force.
Comparison of Brands’ Blade Thickness
The blade thickness of the tested screwdriver brands was compared, with Wera and WIA brands having the thickest blades, resulting in their superior performance under high force situations.
Performance in High Force Situations
The screwdrivers’ performance in high force situations was assessed based on their ability to handle stress and resist bending or breaking. Wera and WIA brands were found to perform exceptionally well in such scenarios.
Results: Stress and Impact Handling
Key Findings
The stress and impact handling test evaluated the screwdrivers’ performance under hammer blows and hydraulic press tests. The findings indicated significant differences in the ability of the screwdrivers to withstand stress and impact.
Performance under Hammer Blows
The screwdrivers’ performance under hammer blows was assessed, with brands such as Milwaukee, Craftsman, Vessel, WIA, and Klein Tools demonstrating good resilience and structural integrity throughout the testing.
Hydraulic Press Tests
The hydraulic press tests measured the failure load of the screwdrivers under increasing pressure. The Pittsburgh brand performed reasonably well for a budget tool, while other brands showed varying results in terms of maximum load resistance.
Analysis of Failure Load
The failure load analysis revealed differences in the maximum load resistance among the screwdriver brands. Craftsman’s handle began bending at 650 pounds, Tecton’s handle experienced movement at 170 pounds, and Weira’s shaft started moving at 700 pounds and bending at 1500 pounds.
This image is property of images.unsplash.com.
Results: Chemical Resistance
Key Findings
The chemical resistance test evaluated the handles of the screwdrivers after exposure to brake parts cleaner. Craftsman and Channel Lock’s handles became soft after exposure, indicating limited solvent resistance.
Exposure to Brake Parts Cleaner
The screwdriver handles were exposed to brake parts cleaner to assess their resistance to solvents. Craftsman and Channel Lock handles showed signs of softening, suggesting a potential decrease in quality and durability.
Effects on Handle Quality
The exposure to brake parts cleaner had a negative effect on the handle quality of certain screwdriver brands. Craftsman and Channel Lock handles experienced softening, which could impact their long-term durability.
Conclusion
Summary of Test Results
The testing conducted by Project Farm LLC revealed significant variations in the durability and performance of different screwdriver brands. German brands, such as Wera, Wiha, and WIA, consistently performed well in terms of wear resistance, grip resistance, and overall durability. Other brands, including Craftsman, Milwaukee, and Vessel, also demonstrated satisfactory performance with some variations.
Importance of Choosing Reliable Screwdriver Brands
The test results highlight the importance of choosing reliable screwdriver brands that can withstand wear, provide a secure grip, and offer long-term durability. German brands, with their superior performance, are recommended for those seeking high-quality and long-lasting screwdrivers.
Acknowledgment of Viewer-Suggested Videos
Project Farm LLC acknowledges and features viewer-suggested videos on their channel. This allows viewers to actively engage and contribute to the testing process, further enriching the information provided.
